SEO Turn up the volume on your visibility

SEO Audit Checklist: A DIY Guide for Business Owners

A step-by-step DIY SEO audit for business owners: indexing, speed, on-page, content, links, local SEO, schema and tracking, using free tools like Search Console.

  • By Derek Schmidt
  • Published
  • Updated
  • 7 min read

An SEO audit is a checkup on how easily Google can find, read and trust your website. You can run a solid one yourself in an afternoon with free tools: Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, the Rich Results Test and a site crawler. Work through the eight sections below in order, fix what you find, and repeat the quick version every quarter.

You do not need to be technical to do this. Most of the problems that hold small business sites back are easy to spot once you know where to look: pages Google never indexed, titles that all say the same thing, a slow homepage, or a Google Business Profile that does not match the website. This checklist walks you through each one.

What You Need Before You Start

  • Google Search Console. Free, and the only place Google tells you directly how it sees your site. If you have not set it up, do that first and give it a few days to collect data.
  • PageSpeed Insights. Free speed and Core Web Vitals scores for any page.
  • A site crawler. Screaming Frog’s free version crawls up to 500 URLs, which covers most small business sites. It lists every page with its title, description, headings and status code.
  • Google’s Rich Results Test. Checks the structured data (schema) on a page.
  • A spreadsheet. Write down every issue, the page it is on and whether it is fixed. An audit you do not track is an audit you will repeat.

1. Can Google Find And Index Your Pages?

Nothing else matters if your important pages are not in Google’s index. Start here.

  • Open Search Console, go to Indexing, then Pages. Look at the “Why pages aren’t indexed” list. Some exclusions are normal (redirects, pages you marked noindex on purpose). Pages you want found showing up as “Crawled, currently not indexed” or “Not found (404)” are not.
  • Use URL Inspection on your homepage and your top service pages. Each one should say “URL is on Google.”
  • Check that your XML sitemap is submitted under Sitemaps and shows a “Success” status.
  • Open yourdomain.com/robots.txt and make sure it is not blocking pages you want in search.
  • In your crawler, filter for pages with a noindex tag and confirm each one is meant to be hidden.
  • Look for duplicate versions of the same page (with and without www, http and https, trailing slashes). They should all redirect to one version.

2. Is The Site Fast And Mobile-Friendly?

Most local searches happen on phones, and a slow page loses people before it loads.

  • In Search Console, open Core Web Vitals. It shows which pages Google rates good, needing improvement or poor based on real visitors.
  • Run your homepage and two or three key pages through PageSpeed Insights on mobile. Google’s “good” targets are a Largest Contentful Paint of 2.5 seconds or less, Interaction to Next Paint of 200 milliseconds or less, and Cumulative Layout Shift of 0.1 or less.
  • The usual culprits are oversized images, too many plugins or scripts, and slow hosting. Compress images and serve them in WebP before you try anything fancier.
  • Open the site on your own phone. Can you read it without zooming, tap the buttons easily and find your phone number in one second?

Our website speed optimization guide goes deeper on the fixes.

3. Are Your Pages Optimized On-Page?

Export your crawl and sort by page. For every page that matters:

  • Title tag: unique, describes the page and includes the main thing people search for. Around 50 to 60 characters keeps it from being cut off in results.
  • Meta description: unique, written for a human, and gives a reason to click. Missing or duplicate descriptions show up instantly in a crawler.
  • One H1 that says what the page is about, with H2s that break the page into clear sections.
  • Images have descriptive alt text and file names that make sense.
  • Internal links: every important page gets linked from other relevant pages with descriptive anchor text, not “click here.”
  • Clean URLs that are short and readable.

For the full list, see our on-page SEO checklist.

4. Is Your Content Helpful, Current And Clearly Yours?

Google rewards content written for people, by people who know the subject. Look at your site with fresh eyes.

  • Thin pages: service pages with a paragraph or two rarely rank. Each core service deserves a real page that answers what a customer would ask before calling you.
  • Duplicate content: location or service pages that only swap a town name are a red flag. Make each one genuinely useful for that place or that service.
  • Outdated posts: update or retire old posts with stale years in the title, broken advice or dead links.
  • Who wrote it: blog posts should name a real author with a short bio. Readers and Google both want to know who is behind the advice.
  • Answer the question first: put the direct answer near the top of each page, then the detail. That is also how AI search tools pick what to quote.
  • In Search Console, open Links to see which sites link to you and which of your pages get the most links.
  • Fix broken internal links (your crawler lists every 404) and redirect old URLs that still have links pointing at them.
  • Look for easy, legitimate links you are missing: your chamber of commerce, local associations, suppliers, sponsorships and partners.
  • Do not panic about spammy-looking links from sites you have never heard of. Google ignores most of them. Disavowing links is rarely needed for a small business.
  • Never buy links. It is the fastest way to turn an audit into a cleanup project.

6. Is Your Local SEO In Order?

If you serve customers in a specific area, this section is where most of your calls come from.

  • Google Business Profile: correct primary category, every service listed, accurate hours, real photos and a link to the right page on your site.
  • NAP consistency: your business name, address and phone number should match exactly across your website, Google, Bing, Apple Maps, Yelp, Facebook and major directories.
  • Reviews: a steady flow of recent reviews, and a reply to every one of them, good or bad.
  • Location pages: if you serve several towns, each important one deserves a page with real local detail.

Our guides to Google Business Profile optimization and NAP consistency cover each step.

7. Is Your Structured Data Working?

  • Run your homepage, a service page and a blog post through Google’s Rich Results Test.
  • At minimum you want Organization or LocalBusiness markup on your homepage, BreadcrumbList on inner pages and Article or BlogPosting on posts, with the author named.
  • Fix anything the test flags as an error. Warnings are worth a look but rarely urgent.
  • In Search Console, check the Enhancements section for structured data problems Google found while crawling.

8. Can You Measure What SEO Brings In?

  • Google Analytics 4 is installed on every page and records your key actions as conversions: form submissions, phone calls, booked appointments.
  • Search Console is linked to Analytics so you can see which searches lead to which pages.
  • You know your baseline: clicks, impressions and conversions from organic search for the last three months. Without it you cannot tell whether next quarter’s work paid off.

How Often Should You Run An SEO Audit?

Run a quick version of sections 1, 2 and 6 every quarter. It takes about an hour once you have done it before. Do the full audit once a year, and always before and right after a website redesign, because a redesign is the most common way small businesses lose rankings they already earned.

Planning a new site? Pair this with our website redesign checklist, and if you want to go further into the technical side, read our technical SEO audit guide.

When To Bring In A Pro

A DIY audit catches most of the obvious problems. It is time to call someone when your traffic dropped and you cannot find out why, when Search Console shows hundreds of pages excluded, when you are planning a redesign or a move to a new platform, or when you simply would rather spend the afternoon running your business. Tell us what you are seeing and we will tell you, in plain language, what we would fix first.

SEO Audit FAQ

How long does a DIY SEO audit take?

For a small business site with under 100 pages, plan on two to four hours the first time. A quarterly check of the most important sections takes about an hour.

Do I need paid tools to audit my website?

No. Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, the Rich Results Test and the free version of a crawler like Screaming Frog cover everything on this checklist for most small business sites.

What should I fix first?

Start with indexing problems on pages you want found, then speed and mobile issues on your most visited pages, then your Google Business Profile if you serve a local area. Those three usually move the needle fastest.

How often should I audit my site?

Do a quick check every quarter and a full audit once a year, plus before and after any website redesign.

Filed under SEO

SEO Services Free resources

Written By

Derek Schmidt

CEO & Founder, DesignLoud

Derek Schmidt is the founder of DesignLoud, the Wilmington, NC digital marketing and web design agency he started in 2011, and of SWELL Systems, a Wilmington SaaS company. He hosts the Entrepreneur Bootcamp Podcast, teaches at the Cape Fear Community College Small Business Center and is a two-time 40 Under 40 honoree. Derek reviews every post on Liner Notes before it goes live.

Encore

Get The Next Liner Notes First

New guides on SEO, web design, ads and AI, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

Rather Talk It Through?

Bring us the problem. We will bring the plan.

DesignLoud has been helping businesses get found since 2011. Tell us what you are working on and we will tell you, in plain language, what we would do.